Just beyond the dune, steps from a quiet stretch of beach, you’ll find this lovingly kept 3 bedroom, 2 bath beach cottage–a true slice of Cape Cod charm. Tucked away on Lieutenant’s Island, this is a place where time slows down, nature surrounds you, and the sounds of the sea and birdsong set the tone for the day. The cottage is full of simple pleasures: bay breezes drifting across the oversized decks that wrap around three sides, sun-filled spaces that invite you to unwind, and a peaceful setting perfect for bird watching, beachcombing, or just being still. A short path leads to shared stairs that take you directly to the sand–close enough for a morning swim, sunset stroll, or a day with your toes in the tide. With a strong rental history and generations of family memories within its walls, this home offers both personal retreat and investment potential. Lieutenant’s Island, bordered by the Massachusetts Audubon sanctuary, is known for its untouched beauty, quiet roads, brilliant stargazing, and unmatched sunsets. If you’re searching for a place to reconnect–with nature, with simplicity, with yourself–this is it. Once you arrive, you won’t want to leave. Seller welcomes offers with request for buyer concessions.
Property Details
Price:
$1,149,000
MLS #:
22501669
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Baths:
2
Address:
11 Arthur Cashin Way
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
City:
Wellfleet
Listed Date:
Apr 15, 2025
State:
MA
Finished Sq Ft:
1,507
Total Sq Ft:
1,507
ZIP:
02667
Year Built:
1930
See this Listing
Will was born in Denver, Colorado and raised in Granby, Connecticut on a 22 acre farm. From a very young age He spent his summers vacationing and working on Cape Cod. After earning his bachelor degree in Political Science from Connecticut College, he moved to Chatham and began work at the May School for Child Development. Will worked there for about 5 ½ years and then decided to pursue a career in real estate. He started off by receiving his salesperson license and soon thereafter he obtained a…
More About WilliamMortgage Calculator
Schools
School District:
Nauset
Interior
Appliances
Water Heater, Electric Water Heater
Bathrooms
2 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Wall Unit(s)
Flooring
Wood, Carpet, Tile
Exterior
Architectural Style
Cottage
Association Amenities
Road Maintenance
Construction Materials
Shingle Siding
Exterior Features
Outdoor Shower, Yard
Roof
Asphalt, Pitched
Financial
HOA Fee
$200
HOA Frequency
Annually
HOA Includes
Reserve Funds
Tax Year
2025
Taxes
$7,934
Map
Community
- Address11 Arthur Cashin Way Wellfleet MA
- CityWellfleet
- CountyBarnstable
- Zip Code02667
Similar Listings Nearby
- 35 Tecumseh Road
Wellfleet, MA$1,275,000
1.46 miles away
- 25 First Avenue
Wellfleet, MA$975,000
1.84 miles away
- 35 Pine Field Road
Wellfleet, MA$925,000
1.93 miles away
- 79 Pinewood Circle
Wellfleet, MA$859,000
1.93 miles away

11 Arthur Cashin Way
Wellfleet, MA
LIGHTBOX-IMAGES